The Taste Test

Written by
Stephanie Adams
Published on
November 18, 2026
How to decide what’s worth making, and how to make it worthwhile.
We all know the conversation. Someone outside of the creative industry proudly announces they’ve designed a brand using the latest generative AI tool. When they share the results, the work is… not amazing. Though, It’s hard to argue their claim because by the most basic of definitions, they did generate a brand identity.
AI has made the world of “what can be done” almost unlimited. However, this expansion does not diminish the worth of professional creatives. It does however place greater emphasis on where their value lies.
The strange reality creatives are now working in is that anyone can be a creator. But even in this environment, taste remains the skill that sets the best work apart. It is cultivated over time, and it’s the instinct that tells us not just what can be done, but what’s actually worth making. I spent some time uncovering how to use AI as a strategic tool that, as creatives, we can lean into while taste remains the filter that defines the work as yours.
The AI landscape is a creative shift, not a creative threat.
Technological advancements are a critical part of the overall creative advancement. Designers specifically rely on digital tools to continue to shape our workflows, processes, and capabilities. Regardless of our reliance on technology, the fear around AI in the industry is warranted. When generative AI became widely accessible, large companies began leaning all the way in by creating entire commercials featuring visuals made solely from AI tools, i.e. Coca Cola’s viral 2024 AI Holiday Ad made by Secret Level, Silverside AI and Wild Card. What these companies did not anticipate, viewers were not pleased by being served a generated commercial, and in some cases, the wide scale sentiment was that these outputs feel “devoid of any actual creativity” as written by Bruna Horvath in a 2024 article reviewing Coca-colas’s ad. Brands have since changed their usage strategy of AI.


An entirely AI generated output is not how creatives are successfully using AI. The generative tools speed up some production assets, but do not have the ability to supply judgment, context, or intent that viewers yearn for. When Coca-Cola released their AI commercial, the public’s poor reaction was not solely because it visually looked generated, it was because it lacked the creative strategy, taste, and intentionality that is required for a successful creative output.
This doesn’t mean AI is not an incredibly important asset. Creatives who build AI into their processes deliberately have more time for the strategic development of the work that clients actually pay for, and the public wants to see.
Taste is Irreplaceable
AI is very good at producing the probable, meaning the average of what already exists. Taste recognizes cultural associations, audience awareness, a human sense of what’s right at the moment, and personal perspective. Precisely, taste is about the improbable, the antithesis of AI.
Whether or not you are using an AI tool, the creative process is iterative. It requires you to be both a creator and a curator, which takes a level of information and knowledge, and always requires taste. It is widely recognized that an initial concept rarely represents your finest work. The ability to expand on that first idea, developing, refining, and polishing an initial concept relies entirely on the unique human capacity for taste.
Creatives have found a sweet spot using AI to generate high volume and rapid options, while retaining human judgment to maintain quality.

Where AI Is helpful:
- Enhance your productivity.
Use it to help resize things, create quick mock ups and drafts, summarize interviews and articles, and gather mood boards so more of your time goes into the strategic work and not the prep work.
- Test your Ideas.
AI platforms can prototype initial concepts for team feedback or act as a sounding board to challenge your thinking and pinpoint potential blind spots.
- Support experimentation.
These platforms are most effective when applied toward deepening your understanding. Curiosity is a pillar of creativity, and AI offers a new domain to investigate and push boundaries within.
Where taste has to lead:
- The Why.
The creative strategy and intention behind the work feels authentic only when it comes from people.
- Your Point of View.
These tools are widely accessible to everyone and patterns inevitably arise. Do not let this flatten your education, perspective, and cultural associations, that is your edge.
- Quality versus Quantity.
A higher volume of options does not translate to higher value. Maintain both objective standards and subjective judgement when evaluating AI outputs, balancing core design principles and audience goals alongside your personal perspective.
- Originality.
With the overwhelming volume of content encountered each day, introducing a distinct, disruptive perspective is essential.
Taste is not innate; it is cultivated through exposure, reflection, and experimentation
Dr Jodi Nelson-Tabor, Director of MARS Academy
Taste extends beyond a trained eye or individual aesthetic. It is a specialized capability developed through deliberate curation, collaborative discussion, audience engagement, feedback, and cultural impact. While generative AI tools expand possibilities, human taste remains the central pillar guiding creative decisions for industry success. Allow AI to expand your possibilities, but rely on your own taste to define what is truly worth putting into the world.







































